http://arxiv.org/abs/2005.08029
Using the Pantheon data set of Type Ia supernovae, \cite{Ringermacher2020} (R20 henceforth) report a $~2\sigma$ detection of oscillations in the expansion history of the universe. Applying the R20 methodology to simulated Pantheon data, we determine that these oscillations likely arise from analysis artifacts. The uneven spacing of Type Ia supernovae in redshift space and the complicated analysis method of R20 impose a structured throughput function. When analyzed with the R20 prescription, about $11\%$ of artificial $\Lambda$CDM data sets produce a stronger oscillatory signal than the actual Pantheon data. The study conducted by R20 is a wholly worthwhile endeavor. However, we believe that the detected oscillations are not due to an oscillating cosmic scale factor and are instead artifacts of the data processing. Our results underscore the importance of understanding the false `signals’ that can be introduced by complicated data analyses.
S. Scolnic
Tue, 19 May 20
27/92
Comments: N/A
You must be logged in to post a comment.