We study the origin of the soft X-ray excess seen in the ‘simple’ Narrow Line Seyfert 1 PG1244+026 using all the spectral-timing information. This object shows the standard switch between soft leading the hard band on long timescales, to the opposite behaviour on short timescales. This is interpreted as a combination of intrinsic fluctuations propagating down through the accretion flow giving the soft lead, together with reflection of the hard X-rays giving the soft lag. We build a full model of the spectral and time variability including both propagation and reflection, and compare our model with the observed power spectra, coherence, covariance, lag-frequency and lag-energy spectra. We compare models based on a separate soft excess component with those based on reflection dominated soft emission.
Reflection dominated spectra have difficulty reproducing the soft lead at low frequency since reflection will always lag. They also suffer from high coherence and nearly identical hard and soft band power spectra in disagreement with the observations. This is a direct result of the power law and reflection component both contributing to the hard and soft energy bands and the small radii over which the relativistically smeared reflection is produced transmitting too much high frequency power into the soft band.
Conversely, we find that the separate soft excess models (where the inner disc radius > 6Rg) have difficulty reproducing the soft lag at high frequency, as the reflected flux does not contribute enough signal at soft energies to overwhelm the soft lead. However, reflection should also be accompanied by reprocessing, and this should add to the soft excess at low energies. This model can quantitatively reproduce the switch from soft lead to soft lag seen in the data and reproduces well the observed power spectra and other timing features which reflection dominated models cannot.
E. Gardner and C. Done
Thu, 13 Mar 14